PennyDreadfulCommander
PD EDH
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Back_Alley_G,TrotterTime,wappla,Maelstrom004

== Game 1 (591564554) ==
PDBot has started watching.
wappla joined the game.
TrotterTime joined the game.
Back_Alley_G joined the game.
Maelstrom004 chooses to play first.
Maelstrom004 chooses [Sachi, Daughter of Seshiro] as their commander.
TrotterTime chooses [Nath of the Gilt-Leaf] as their commander.
wappla chooses [Selvala, Explorer Returned] as their commander.
Back_Alley_G chooses [Wydwen, the Biting Gale] as their commander.
Maelstrom004 mulligans to 7 cards.
TrotterTime keeps this hand.
wappla mulligans to 7 cards.
Back_Alley_G keeps this hand.
Maelstrom004 keeps this hand.
wappla keeps this hand.
Turn 1: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 plays [Forest].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: gl and hf folks
[CHAT] wappla: gl
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: glhf
[CHAT] TrotterTime: glhf!
Turn 1: TrotterTime
TrotterTime plays [Golgari Guildgate].
Turn 1: wappla
wappla plays [Forest].
Turn 1: Back_Alley_G
Back_Alley_G plays [Swamp].
Turn 2: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 plays [Forest].
Maelstrom004 casts [Wolf-Skull Shaman].
Turn 2: TrotterTime
TrotterTime plays [Swamp].
Turn 2: wappla
wappla plays [Desert of the True].
Turn 2: Back_Alley_G
Back_Alley_G plays [Island].
Back_Alley_G casts [Silver Myr].
Turn 3: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...).
Maelstrom004 plays [Forest].
Maelstrom004 casts [Troll Ascetic].
Turn 3: TrotterTime
TrotterTime plays [Swamp].
TrotterTime casts [Golgari Keyrune].
Turn 3: wappla
wappla casts [Sylvan Ranger].
wappla puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
wappla reveals [Plains].
wappla plays [Plains].
Turn 3: Back_Alley_G
Back_Alley_G plays [Swamp].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: hey, trotter who will you target with your commander discard if you cast it?
[CHAT] TrotterTime: ooh well that's a tough question I tell ya
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: well, i have proposal. I won't counter your commander if you don't target me 
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: temporary truce more or less
[CHAT] TrotterTime: i'll take that deal
Back_Alley_G casts [Cultivator's Caravan].
Turn 4: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...).
Maelstrom004's [Wolf-Skull Shaman] creates a Wolf token.
Maelstrom004 reveals [Tajuru Preserver].
Maelstrom004 plays [Spawning Bed].
Maelstrom004 casts [Llanowar Empath].
Maelstrom004 puts triggered ability from [Llanowar Empath] onto the stack (When Llanowar Empath enters the battlefield, scry 2, then reveal the top card of your library. If ...).
Maelstrom004 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Maelstrom004 put a card on top of Maelstrom004's library.
Maelstrom004 reveals [Silklash Spider] with [Llanowar Empath]'s ability.
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: can I also negotiate a deal not to be discarded?
[CHAT] TrotterTime: depends on the deal, making deals with everyone makes the deck redundant
TrotterTime is being attacked by [Troll Ascetic] and [Wolf-Skull Shaman].
Turn 4: TrotterTime
TrotterTime casts [Brink of Madness].
Turn 4: wappla
wappla plays [Forest].
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: nah, just means everyone gangs up on the person with the least leverage
wappla casts [Selvala, Explorer Returned].
Turn 4: Back_Alley_G
Back_Alley_G plays [Island].
Turn 5: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...).
Maelstrom004's [Wolf-Skull Shaman] creates a Wolf token.
Maelstrom004 reveals [Gigantomancer].
[CHAT] TrotterTime: what's what's your deal?
[CHAT] TrotterTime: well*
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: not swinging out I guess, thats all this deck can really do
Maelstrom004 casts [Sachi, Daughter of Seshiro].
[CHAT] TrotterTime: okay that's fine then
Back_Alley_G casts [Disdainful Stroke] targeting [Sachi, Daughter of Seshiro].
Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Llanowar Empath], [Wolf] token, [Troll Ascetic], and [Wolf-Skull Shaman].
Back_Alley_G casts [Wydwen, the Biting Gale].
[Wydwen, the Biting Gale] blocks [Troll Ascetic].
Turn 5: TrotterTime
TrotterTime casts [Liliana's Reaver].
Turn 5: wappla
Back_Alley_G reveals [Nephalia Drownyard].
Maelstrom004 reveals [Thornbite Staff].
TrotterTime reveals [Imperious Perfect].
wappla reveals [Selesnya Sanctuary].
[CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Thornbite Staff[sU] has a Graphical bug.  Thornbite Staff doesn't display the equip cost line when zoomed in upon.
wappla casts [Felidar Sovereign].
wappla plays [Selesnya Sanctuary].
wappla puts triggered ability from [Selesnya Sanctuary] onto the stack (When Selesnya Sanctuary enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
wappla returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with [Selesnya Sanctuary]'s ability.
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: well something needs to die
wappla discards [Filigree Familiar].
Turn 5: Back_Alley_G
Back_Alley_G casts [Careful Consideration] (Enhanced) targeting Back_Alley_G.
Back_Alley_G draws four cards with [Careful Consideration].
Back_Alley_G discards [Desert of the Glorified].
Back_Alley_G discards [Swamp].
[CHAT] TrotterTime: if you can bounce it i can try discard it
Back_Alley_G plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: I can't do anything sadly
Turn 6: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...).
[CHAT] TrotterTime: so i've now go to peel removal
[CHAT] TrotterTime: got*
[CHAT] TrotterTime: actually we just need to get wappla below 40 health before his upkeep
wappla is being attacked by [Wolf] token, [Llanowar Empath], [Wolf] token, and [Wolf-Skull Shaman].
DavocK has started watching.
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: I don't think we can even do that atm
[CHAT] TrotterTime: yes we can
[Felidar Sovereign] blocks [Wolf-Skull Shaman].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: lifelink though 
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: not with lifelink
[CHAT] TrotterTime: i've done the math 
[CHAT] TrotterTime: i still have an attack next turn
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: oh yeah, forgot about the charm
DavocK has stopped watching.
Maelstrom004 plays [Forest].
Maelstrom004 casts [Predator, Flagship].
Turn 6: TrotterTime
TrotterTime activates an ability of [Golgari Keyrune] ( Golgari Keyrune becomes a 2/2 black and green Insect artifact creature with deathtouch until end ...).
wappla is being attacked by [Liliana's Reaver] and [Golgari Keyrune].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: keyrune I mean
[Sylvan Ranger] blocks [Liliana's Reaver].
[CHAT] TrotterTime: hah i got it
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: same difference :P
TrotterTime discards [Dread].
TrotterTime puts triggered ability from [Dread] onto the stack ( When Dread is put into a graveyard from anywhere, shuffle it into its owner's library.).
Turn 6: wappla
wappla plays [Forest].
Back_Alley_G reveals [Thaumatic Compass].
Maelstrom004 reveals [Forest].
TrotterTime reveals [Ant Queen].
wappla reveals [Plains].
wappla casts [Enter the Unknown] targeting [Felidar Sovereign].
wappla reveals [Waker of the Wilds] with [Enter the Unknown].
wappla's [Felidar Sovereign] explores, revealing [Waker of the Wilds].
wappla plays [Plains].
wappla casts [Mass Calcify].
[CHAT] TrotterTime: again a bounce spell does it
Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Felidar Sovereign].
Turn 6: Back_Alley_G
Back_Alley_G plays [Nephalia Drownyard].
Back_Alley_G casts [Kumena's Awakening].
Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
Turn 7: Maelstrom004
Maelstrom004 plays [Forest].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: oh wait, awakening doesn't help anybody else until my next turn. oh well. hopefully someone draws soethign regardless
[CHAT] Maelstrom004: missed a land drop, mana short
Maelstrom004 casts [Masked Admirers].
[CHAT] Back_Alley_G: was a mana short myself also 
[CHAT] TrotterTime: i have a hand full of late-game stuff rn and mana screwed so
Maelstrom004 puts triggered ability from [Masked Admirers] onto the stack (When Masked Admirers enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
Maelstrom004 draws a card with [Masked Admirers]'s ability.
Maelstrom004 casts [Tajuru Preserver].
Turn 7: TrotterTime
TrotterTime plays [Swamp].
TrotterTime casts [Remorseless Punishment] targeting wappla.
wappla chooses Discard for [Remorseless Punishment].
wappla discards [Ant Queen].
wappla discards [Kjeldoran Outpost].
wappla chooses Lose Life for [Remorseless Punishment].
Turn 7: wappla
wappla puts triggered ability from [Felidar Sovereign] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if you have 40 or more life, you win the game.).
Winner: wappla
Game 1 Completed.
TrotterTime has left the game.
Back_Alley_G has left the game.
wappla has left the game.