PennyDreadful
PD League
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
jenkin5630,Merawder

== Game 1 (588989002) ==
PDBot has started watching.
[League] Violent Con V5 by jenkin5630 (10246) vs Birthday Stax by merawder (10247)
[CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
Merawder chooses to play first.
Merawder keeps this hand.
jenkin5630 keeps this hand.
Turn 1: Merawder
Merawder skips their draw step.
Merawder plays [Seaside Citadel].
Turn 1: jenkin5630
[CHAT] Merawder: heya
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on top of jenkin5630's library.
Turn 2: Merawder
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
Turn 2: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 casts [Skyshroud Ranger].
jenkin5630 plays [Gruul Turf].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Gruul Turf] onto the stack (When Gruul Turf enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
jenkin5630 returns [Temple of Mystery] to its owner's hand with [Gruul Turf]'s ability.
Turn 3: Merawder
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Sailor of Means].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Sailor of Means] onto the stack (When Sailor of Means enters the battlefield, create a colorless Treasure artifact token with '{T},...).
Merawder's [Sailor of Means] creates a Treasure token.
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Palace Familiar].
Turn 3: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on the bottom of the library.
jenkin5630 activates an ability of [Skyshroud Ranger] ( You may put a land card from your hand onto the battlefield.).
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on top of jenkin5630's library.
Turn 4: Merawder
Merawder discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Sailor of Means] and [Palace Familiar].
Turn 4: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Swamp].
Merawder is being attacked by [Skyshroud Ranger].
Turn 5: Merawder
Merawder plays [Tranquil Garden].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Sailor of Means] and [Palace Familiar].
Merawder casts [Sailor of Means].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Sailor of Means] onto the stack (When Sailor of Means enters the battlefield, create a colorless Treasure artifact token with '{T},...).
Merawder's [Sailor of Means] creates a Treasure token.
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
jenkin5630 casts [Burst Lightning] (with kicker) targeting [Sailor of Means].
Turn 5: jenkin5630
Merawder is being attacked by [Skyshroud Ranger].
Turn 6: Merawder
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Sailor of Means] and [Palace Familiar].
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder plays [Cloudcrest Lake].
jenkin5630 casts [Stroke of Genius] targeting jenkin5630. (X is 2).
jenkin5630 draws two cards with [Stroke of Genius].
Turn 6: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Island].
Merawder is being attacked by [Skyshroud Ranger].
Merawder casts [Perilous Research].
Merawder draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
Merawder sacrifices [Palace Familiar].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Palace Familiar] onto the stack (When Palace Familiar dies, draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Palace Familiar]'s ability.
Turn 7: Merawder
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder casts [Gift of Immortality] targeting [Sailor of Means].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Sailor of Means].
Merawder casts [Smokestack].
jenkin5630 discards [Shefet Monitor].
jenkin5630 cycles [Shefet Monitor].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack ( When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card...).
jenkin5630 casts [Counterflux] targeting [Smokestack].
Merawder casts [Unsubstantiate] targeting [Counterflux].
Merawder returns [Counterflux] to its owner's hand with [Unsubstantiate].
Turn 7: jenkin5630
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Merawder is being attacked by [Skyshroud Ranger].
Turn 8: Merawder
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may put a soot counter on Smokestack.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
Merawder discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Sailor of Means].
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
Turn 8: jenkin5630
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
jenkin5630 sacrifices [Skyshroud Ranger].
jenkin5630 plays [Vivid Marsh].
jenkin5630 casts [All Suns' Dawn] targeting, [Stroke of Genius] (blue card), [Burst Lightning] (red card), and [Shefet Monitor] (green card).
jenkin5630 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Palace Familiar].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Palace Familiar] onto the stack (When Palace Familiar dies, draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Palace Familiar]'s ability.
jenkin5630 discards [Counterflux].
Turn 9: Merawder
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may put a soot counter on Smokestack.).
Merawder sacrifices [Gift of Immortality].
Merawder sacrifices [Sailor of Means].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Sailor of Means] onto the stack (When Sailor of Means enters the battlefield, create a colorless Treasure artifact token with '{T},...).
Merawder's [Sailor of Means] creates a Treasure token.
Merawder plays [Seaside Citadel].
Merawder casts [Surveilling Sprite].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Sailor of Means at the beginning of the ...).
Turn 9: jenkin5630
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
jenkin5630 discards [Shefet Monitor].
jenkin5630 cycles [Shefet Monitor].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack ( When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card...).
jenkin5630 sacrifices [Island].
jenkin5630 sacrifices [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 plays [Forest].
jenkin5630 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Merawder
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (588990378) ==
PDBot has started watching.
jenkin5630 chooses to play first.
jenkin5630 keeps this hand.
Merawder mulligans to 6 cards.
Merawder mulligans to 5 cards.
Merawder keeps this hand.
Turn 1: jenkin5630
Merawder put a card on the bottom of the library.
jenkin5630 skips their draw step.
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 1: Merawder
Merawder plays [Lonely Sandbar].
Turn 2: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Island].
Turn 2: Merawder
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Turn 3: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Swamp].
Turn 3: Merawder
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
jenkin5630 casts [Soul Manipulation] targeting [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Counter target creature spell.).
Turn 4: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Gruul Turf].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Gruul Turf] onto the stack (When Gruul Turf enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
PennyDreadful
PD League
BuggedCardObserver, LeagueObserver, PennyDreadfulLegality
jenkin5630,Merawder

PDBot has started watching.
[League] Violent Con V5 by jenkin5630 (10246) vs Birthday Stax by merawder (10247)
[CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
jenkin5630 casts [Overwhelming Denial] for its surge cost targeting [Palace Familiar].
Merawder plays [Seaside Citadel].
Turn 8: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Vivid Marsh].
Merawder is being attacked by [Skyshroud Ranger].
Turn 8: Merawder
Merawder casts [Palace Familiar].
jenkin5630 discards [Shefet Monitor].
jenkin5630 cycles [Shefet Monitor].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack ( When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card...).
Turn 9: jenkin5630
Merawder is being attacked by [Skyshroud Ranger].
[Palace Familiar] blocks [Skyshroud Ranger].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Palace Familiar] onto the stack (When Palace Familiar dies, draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Palace Familiar]'s ability.
jenkin5630 casts [Violent Ultimatum] targeting [Seaside Citadel], [Tranquil Garden], and [Lonely Sandbar].
Merawder casts [Unsubstantiate] targeting [Violent Ultimatum].
Merawder returns [Violent Ultimatum] to its owner's hand with [Unsubstantiate].
Turn 9: Merawder
Merawder has conceded from the game.
Winner: jenkin5630
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 3 (588991196) ==
PDBot has started watching.
jenkin5630 joined the game.
Merawder chooses to play first.
Merawder keeps this hand.
jenkin5630 mulligans to 6 cards.
jenkin5630 keeps this hand.
Turn 1: Merawder
jenkin5630 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Merawder skips their draw step.
Merawder plays [Island].
Turn 1: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Vivid Marsh].
Turn 2: Merawder
Merawder plays [Island].
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Turn 2: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 3: Merawder
Merawder plays [Cloudcrest Lake].
Merawder casts [Gift of Immortality] targeting [Alchemist's Apprentice].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 3: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Gruul Turf].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Gruul Turf] onto the stack (When Gruul Turf enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
jenkin5630 returns [Temple of Mystery] to its owner's hand with [Gruul Turf]'s ability.
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 4: Merawder
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Dimir Signet].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 4: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on top of jenkin5630's library.
Merawder casts [Perilous Research].
Merawder draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
Merawder sacrifices [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 5: Merawder
Merawder plays [Tranquil Garden].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder casts [Smokestack].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
jenkin5630 casts [Naturalize] targeting [Smokestack].
Merawder casts [Perilous Research].
Merawder draws two cards with [Perilous Research].
Merawder sacrifices [Smokestack].
jenkin5630's [Naturalize] is countered because it has no legal targets.
Merawder discards [Tranquil Garden].
Turn 5: jenkin5630
jenkin5630 casts [Thought Hemorrhage] targeting Merawder.
jenkin5630 names Sagu Mauler for [Thought Hemorrhage].
Merawder reveals their hand to [Thought Hemorrhage], containing [Surveilling Sprite], [Smokestack], [Plains], [Alchemist's Apprentice], [Smokestack], [Unsubstantiate], and [Gift of Immortality].
[CHAT] Merawder: :P
jenkin5630 plays [Temple of Mystery].
jenkin5630 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
jenkin5630 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 6: Merawder
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder plays [Plains].
Merawder casts [Smokestack].
Merawder casts [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
Turn 6: jenkin5630
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
jenkin5630 plays [Mountain].
jenkin5630 casts [All Suns' Dawn] targeting, [Thought Hemorrhage] (black card), and [Naturalize] (green card).
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, return that card to the battlefield under its owner's control. Retur...).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Gift of Immortality] onto the stack (Return Gift of Immortality to the battlefield attached to Alchemist's Apprentice at the beginning ...).
jenkin5630 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder activates an ability of [Alchemist's Apprentice] (Sacrifice Alchemist's Apprentice: Draw a card.).
Merawder draws a card with [Alchemist's Apprentice]'s ability.
jenkin5630's [Burst Lightning] is countered because it has no legal targets.
Turn 7: Merawder
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may put a soot counter on Smokestack.).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
Merawder plays [Plains].
jenkin5630 is being attacked by [Alchemist's Apprentice].
Merawder casts [Smokestack].
Merawder casts [Smokestack].
Turn 7: jenkin5630
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
Merawder puts triggered ability from [Smokestack] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a permanent for each soot counter...).
jenkin5630 casts [Naturalize] targeting [Smokestack].
jenkin5630 sacrifices [Mountain].
jenkin5630 has conceded from the game.
Winner: Merawder
Game 2 Completed.
jenkin5630 has left the game.