PennyDreadfulCommander Penny Dreadful BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Back_Alley_G,EternalParadox38,TrotterTime == Game 1 (585948644) == PDBot has started watching. Back_Alley_G joined the game. EternalParadox38 joined the game. TrotterTime joined the game. [CHAT] TrotterTime: glhf Back_Alley_G chooses to play first. Back_Alley_G chooses [Etali, Primal Storm] as their commander. TrotterTime chooses [Isperia the Inscrutable] as their commander. EternalParadox38 chooses [Daxos of Meletis] as their commander. [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Etali, Primal Storm[sU] has a Disadvantageous bug. Etali, Primal Storm is unable to cast split cards or multiple cards with additional costs. Back_Alley_G keeps this hand. TrotterTime keeps this hand. EternalParadox38 mulligans to 7 cards. EternalParadox38 keeps this hand. Turn 1: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G plays [Dwarven Ruins]. Turn 1: TrotterTime TrotterTime plays [Island]. Turn 1: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. Turn 2: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G plays [Mountain]. Back_Alley_G casts [Mask of Memory]. Turn 2: TrotterTime TrotterTime plays [Plains]. TrotterTime casts [Azorius Signet]. [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Azorius Signet[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. Turn 2: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 plays [Plains]. EternalParadox38 casts [Soltari Trooper]. Turn 3: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G casts [Manakin]. Turn 3: TrotterTime TrotterTime casts [Resplendent Griffin]. Turn 3: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 casts [Mask of Memory]. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Soltari Trooper]. EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Soltari Trooper] onto the stack (Whenever Soltari Trooper attacks, it gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). [CHAT] TrotterTime: oh shiz Turn 4: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G plays [Spawning Bed]. [CHAT] TrotterTime: lol i thought all the signets were legal [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: they were last season but not this season sadly Back_Alley_G casts [Ur-Golem's Eye]. [CHAT] TrotterTime: argh Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Manakin] (Equip {1}). Turn 4: TrotterTime TrotterTime casts [Warden of Evos Isle]. EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Resplendent Griffin]. Turn 4: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 plays [Tranquil Cove]. EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Soltari Trooper] (Equip {1}). TrotterTime is being attacked by [Soltari Trooper]. EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Soltari Trooper] onto the stack (Whenever Soltari Trooper attacks, it gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Mask of Memory] onto the stack (Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw two cards. If you do, dis...). EternalParadox38 draws two cards with [Mask of Memory]'s ability. EternalParadox38 discards [Strata Scythe]. EternalParadox38 casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. Turn 5: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G casts [Etali, Primal Storm]. Turn 5: TrotterTime TrotterTime plays [Tranquil Cove]. TrotterTime puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). TrotterTime casts [Fog Bank]. Turn 5: EternalParadox38 TrotterTime is being attacked by [Soltari Trooper]. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Soltari Trooper] onto the stack (Whenever Soltari Trooper attacks, it gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Mask of Memory] onto the stack (Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw two cards. If you do, dis...). EternalParadox38 draws two cards with [Mask of Memory]'s ability. EternalParadox38 discards [Deadeye Quartermaster]. EternalParadox38 casts [Imprisoned in the Moon] targeting [Etali, Primal Storm]. Turn 6: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G plays [Urza's Factory]. Back_Alley_G casts [Pristine Talisman]. Back_Alley_G casts [Kamahl, Pit Fighter]. Turn 6: TrotterTime TrotterTime casts [Isperia the Inscrutable]. Turn 6: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. EternalParadox38 casts [Military Intelligence]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Kamahl, Pit Fighter] targeting [Soltari Trooper] ( Kamahl, Pit Fighter deals 3 damage to target creature or player.). Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. EternalParadox38 casts [Candles of Leng]. Turn 7: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G plays [Mountain]. Back_Alley_G casts [Hellkite Charger]. Back_Alley_G casts [Whispersilk Cloak]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Hellkite Charger] (Equip {1}). Turn 7: TrotterTime TrotterTime plays [Plains]. TrotterTime casts [Thunderclap Wyvern]. EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Isperia the Inscrutable]. EternalParadox38 has been dealt 4 total damage by TrotterTime's commander, [Isperia the Inscrutable]. TrotterTime puts triggered ability from [Isperia the Inscrutable] onto the stack (Whenever Isperia the Inscrutable deals combat damage to a player, name a card. That player reveals...). [CHAT] TrotterTime: hmmm TrotterTime names End Hostilities for Triggered ability from Isperia the Inscrutable. EternalParadox38 reveals their hand to [Isperia the Inscrutable]'s ability, containing [Soltari Champion], [Thalakos Dreamsower], [Phantom Warrior], [Deepfathom Skulker], and [Tamiyo's Journal]. Turn 7: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 plays [Desert of the Mindful]. EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Candles of Leng] ( Reveal the top card of your library. If it has the same name as a card in your graveyard, put it ...). EternalParadox38 reveals [Cultivator's Caravan] with [Candles of Leng]'s ability. EternalParadox38 draws a card with [Candles of Leng]'s ability. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Kamahl, Pit Fighter] targeting [Thunderclap Wyvern] ( Kamahl, Pit Fighter deals 3 damage to target creature or player.). Turn 8: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G casts [Scour from Existence] targeting [Imprisoned in the Moon]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Whispersilk Cloak] targeting [Etali, Primal Storm] (Equip {2}). TrotterTime is being attacked by [Etali, Primal Storm]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Etali, Primal Storm] onto the stack (Whenever Etali, Primal Storm attacks, exile the top card of each player's library, then you may ca...). Back_Alley_G casts [Riftwing Cloudskate]. Back_Alley_G discards [Tormenting Voice]. Back_Alley_G casts [Pirate's Pillage]. TrotterTime casts [Silumgar Sorcerer]. TrotterTime puts triggered ability from [Silumgar Sorcerer] onto the stack (Exploit (When this creature enters the battlefield, you may sacrifice a creature.)). TrotterTime sacrifices [Resplendent Griffin]. TrotterTime puts triggered ability from [Silumgar Sorcerer] onto the stack targeting [Riftwing Cloudskate] (When Silumgar Sorcerer exploits a creature, counter target creature spell.). Back_Alley_G draws two cards with [Pirate's Pillage]. Back_Alley_G's [Pirate's Pillage] creates two Treasure tokens. TrotterTime has been dealt 6 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Etali, Primal Storm]. Turn 8: TrotterTime EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Isperia the Inscrutable]. EternalParadox38 has been dealt 7 total damage by TrotterTime's commander, [Isperia the Inscrutable]. TrotterTime puts triggered ability from [Isperia the Inscrutable] onto the stack (Whenever Isperia the Inscrutable deals combat damage to a player, name a card. That player reveals...). TrotterTime names Cultivator's Caravan for Triggered ability from Isperia the Inscrutable. EternalParadox38 reveals their hand to [Isperia the Inscrutable]'s ability, containing [Cultivator's Caravan], [Soltari Champion], [Thalakos Dreamsower], [Phantom Warrior], [Deepfathom Skulker], and [Tamiyo's Journal]. TrotterTime reveals [Purity]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Kamahl, Pit Fighter] targeting [Warden of Evos Isle] ( Kamahl, Pit Fighter deals 3 damage to target creature or player.). TrotterTime casts [Afterlife] targeting [Hellkite Charger]. TrotterTime's [Afterlife] creates a Spirit token under Back_Alley_G's control. Turn 8: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 plays [Plains]. EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald] (Equip {1}). Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Mask of Memory] onto the stack (Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw two cards. If you do, dis...). EternalParadox38 draws two cards with [Mask of Memory]'s ability. EternalParadox38 discards [Phantom Warrior]. EternalParadox38 casts [Wayfarer's Bauble]. EternalParadox38 casts [Cultivator's Caravan]. EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Wayfarer's Bauble] ({2}, {T}, Sacrifice Wayfarer's Bauble: Search your library for a basic land card and put that card...). Turn 9: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G plays [Mountain]. TrotterTime is being attacked by [Etali, Primal Storm]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Etali, Primal Storm] onto the stack (Whenever Etali, Primal Storm attacks, exile the top card of each player's library, then you may ca...). Back_Alley_G casts [Conqueror's Galleon]. Back_Alley_G casts [Slippery Scoundrel]. TrotterTime has been dealt 12 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Etali, Primal Storm]. Back_Alley_G casts [That Which Was Taken]. Turn 9: TrotterTime TrotterTime casts [Custodi Soulbinders]. Turn 9: EternalParadox38 EternalParadox38 casts [Bygone Bishop]. EternalParadox38 casts [Thalakos Dreamsower]. EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.). EternalParadox38's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token. TrotterTime is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Kamahl, Pit Fighter] targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald] ( Kamahl, Pit Fighter deals 3 damage to target creature or player.). EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.). EternalParadox38 draws a card with [Clue] token's ability. EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [That Which Was Taken] targeting [Kamahl, Pit Fighter] ( Put a divinity counter on target permanent other than That Which Was Taken.). Turn 10: Back_Alley_G Back_Alley_G casts [Serum Tank]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Serum Tank] onto the stack (Whenever Serum Tank or another artifact enters the battlefield, put a charge counter on Serum Tank...). Back_Alley_G casts [Golden Guardian]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Serum Tank] onto the stack (Whenever Serum Tank or another artifact enters the battlefield, put a charge counter on Serum Tank...). Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Conqueror's Galleon] (Crew 4). TrotterTime is being attacked by [Etali, Primal Storm]. EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Slippery Scoundrel]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Etali, Primal Storm] onto the stack (Whenever Etali, Primal Storm attacks, exile the top card of each player's library, then you may ca...). Back_Alley_G casts [Mask of Avacyn]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Serum Tank] onto the stack (Whenever Serum Tank or another artifact enters the battlefield, put a charge counter on Serum Tank...). TrotterTime has been dealt 18 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Etali, Primal Storm]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Golden Guardian] targeting [Kamahl, Pit Fighter] ( Golden Guardian fights another target creature you control. When Golden Guardian dies this turn, ...). Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Golden Guardian] onto the stack (When Golden Guardian dies this turn, return it to the battlefield transformed under your control.). Turn 10: TrotterTime [CHAT] TrotterTime: you've hit the lands i needed w etali, gg TrotterTime has conceded from the game. TrotterTime is now a watcher. [CHAT] EternalParadox38: I don't have the cards to deal with this board state EternalParadox38 has conceded from the game. Winner: Back_Alley_G Game 1 Completed.