PennyDreadfulCommander
Penny dreadful
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Kevin_Lelouch,Garyer99

== Game 1 (583479618) ==
PDBot has started watching.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
Garyer99 chooses to play first.
Garyer99 chooses [Vhati il-Dal] as their commander.
Kevin_Lelouch chooses [Horde of Notions] as their commander.
Garyer99 keeps this hand.
Kevin_Lelouch keeps this hand.
Turn 1: Garyer99
Garyer99 skips their draw step.
Garyer99 plays [Forest].
Turn 1: Kevin_Lelouch
Kevin_Lelouch plays [Bloodfell Caves].
Kevin_Lelouch puts triggered ability from [Bloodfell Caves] onto the stack (When Bloodfell Caves enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Bloodfell Caves[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
Turn 2: Garyer99
Garyer99 plays [Foul Orchard].
Turn 2: Kevin_Lelouch
Kevin_Lelouch plays [Mountain].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Smokebraider].
Turn 3: Garyer99
Garyer99 plays [Swamp].
Turn 3: Kevin_Lelouch
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Dimir Signet].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Shinewend].
Turn 4: Garyer99
Garyer99 plays [Swamp].
Garyer99 casts [Grimoire of the Dead].
Turn 4: Kevin_Lelouch
Kevin_Lelouch plays [Savage Lands].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Horde of Notions].
Garyer99 is being attacked by [Horde of Notions] and [Shinewend].
Garyer99 has been dealt 5 total damage by Kevin_Lelouch's commander, [Horde of Notions].
Turn 5: Garyer99
Garyer99 plays [Forest].
Garyer99 casts [Vhati il-Dal].
Turn 5: Kevin_Lelouch
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Rampant Growth].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Seed Guardian].
Garyer99 discards [Baleful Force].
Garyer99 activates an ability of [Grimoire of the Dead] ( Put a study counter on Grimoire of the Dead.).
Garyer99 is being attacked by [Horde of Notions] and [Shinewend].
Garyer99 has been dealt 10 total damage by Kevin_Lelouch's commander, [Horde of Notions].
Turn 6: Garyer99
Garyer99 plays [Forest].
Garyer99 casts [Gutter Grime].
Garyer99 discards [Ogre Slumlord].
Garyer99 activates an ability of [Grimoire of the Dead] ( Put a study counter on Grimoire of the Dead.).
Turn 6: Kevin_Lelouch
Garyer99 is being attacked by [Seed Guardian], [Horde of Notions], and [Shinewend].
[Vhati il-Dal] blocks [Horde of Notions].
Garyer99 activates an ability of [Vhati il-Dal] targeting [Horde of Notions] ( Until end of turn, target creature has base power 1 or base toughness 1.).
Kevin_Lelouch activates an ability of [Shinewend] targeting [Gutter Grime] ( Destroy target enchantment.).
Kevin_Lelouch discards [Rubblehulk].
Kevin_Lelouch activates an ability of [Rubblehulk] targeting [Horde of Notions] ( Target attacking creature gets +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the number of lands you contro...).
Garyer99 has been dealt 16 total damage by Kevin_Lelouch's commander, [Horde of Notions].
Turn 7: Garyer99
Garyer99 plays [Forest].
Garyer99 casts [Vhati il-Dal].
Garyer99 discards [Greenseeker].
Garyer99 activates an ability of [Grimoire of the Dead] ( Put a study counter on Grimoire of the Dead.).
Turn 7: Kevin_Lelouch
Kevin_Lelouch activates an ability of [Horde of Notions] targeting [Rubblehulk] ( You may play target Elemental card from your graveyard without paying its mana cost.).
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Rubblehulk] from the graveyard with [Horde of Notions]'s ability.
Garyer99 is being attacked by [Seed Guardian] and [Horde of Notions].
[Vhati il-Dal] blocks [Horde of Notions].
Garyer99 has been dealt 18 total damage by Kevin_Lelouch's commander, [Horde of Notions].
Turn 8: Garyer99
Garyer99 casts [Jarad's Orders].
Garyer99 reveals [Elvish Aberration].
Garyer99 puts [Elvish Aberration] into hand.
Garyer99 puts [Verdant Sun's Avatar] into their graveyard.
Garyer99 discards [Elvish Aberration].
Garyer99 cycles [Elvish Aberration].
Garyer99 reveals [Forest].
Garyer99 plays [Forest].
Garyer99 activates an ability of [Grimoire of the Dead] ( Put all creature cards from all graveyards onto the battlefield under your control. They're black...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Turn 8: Kevin_Lelouch
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Kevin_Lelouch plays [Forsaken Sanctuary].
Turn 9: Garyer99
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Garyer99 plays [Swamp].
Garyer99 casts [Rishkar's Expertise].
[CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Rishkar's Expertise[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
Garyer99 draws seven cards with [Rishkar's Expertise].
Garyer99 casts [Mitotic Slime] with [Rishkar's Expertise].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 casts [Sanitarium Skeleton].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 casts [Elves of Deep Shadow].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 casts [Pristine Talisman].
Kevin_Lelouch is being attacked by [Shinewend].
[Seed Guardian] blocks [Shinewend].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 discards [Forest].
Garyer99 activates an ability of [Greenseeker] ( Search your library for a basic land card, reveal it, and put it into your hand. Then shuffle you...).
Garyer99 reveals [Swamp].
Kevin_Lelouch activates an ability of [Horde of Notions] targeting [Shinewend] ( You may play target Elemental card from your graveyard without paying its mana cost.).
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Shinewend] from the graveyard with [Horde of Notions]'s ability.
Turn 9: Kevin_Lelouch
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Kevin_Lelouch plays [Island].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Elvish Harbinger].
Kevin_Lelouch puts triggered ability from [Elvish Harbinger] onto the stack (When Elvish Harbinger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for an Elf card, reveal ...).
Kevin_Lelouch fails to find a Elf card.
Turn 10: Garyer99
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Garyer99 casts [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 casts [Consume the Meek].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder] onto the stack ( Whenever a permanent owned by another player is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you dr...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder] onto the stack ( Whenever a permanent owned by another player is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you dr...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder] onto the stack ( Whenever a permanent owned by another player is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you dr...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Kevin_Lelouch activates an ability of [Horde of Notions] targeting [Smokebraider] ( You may play target Elemental card from your graveyard without paying its mana cost.).
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Smokebraider] from the graveyard with [Horde of Notions]'s ability.
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder]'s ability.
Garyer99 draws a card with [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder]'s ability.
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder]'s ability.
Garyer99 discards [Twisted Abomination].
Garyer99 cycles [Twisted Abomination].
Garyer99 reveals [Swamp].
Garyer99 plays [Swamp].
Garyer99 discards [Vampiric Rites].
Turn 10: Kevin_Lelouch
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Arcane Adaptation].
Kevin_Lelouch chooses Elemental for [Arcane Adaptation].
Turn 11: Garyer99
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Garyer99 plays [Golgari Guildgate].
Garyer99 casts [Nekrataal].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Nekrataal] onto the stack targeting [Seed Guardian] (When Nekrataal enters the battlefield, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature. That creatur...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Ogre Slumlord] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature dies, you may create a 1/1 black Rat creature token.).
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder] onto the stack ( Whenever a permanent owned by another player is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, you dr...).
Kevin_Lelouch puts triggered ability from [Seed Guardian] onto the stack (When Seed Guardian dies, create an X/X green Elemental creature token, where X is the number of cr...).
Kevin_Lelouch's [Seed Guardian] creates an Elemental token.
Garyer99 draws a card with [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder]'s ability.
Garyer99's [Ogre Slumlord] creates a Rat token.
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Garyer99 casts [Putrefy] targeting [Horde of Notions].
Kevin_Lelouch activates an ability of [Horde of Notions] targeting [Seed Guardian] ( You may play target Elemental card from your graveyard without paying its mana cost.).
Garyer99 casts [Scour from Existence] targeting [Smokebraider].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Seed Guardian] from the graveyard with [Horde of Notions]'s ability.
Kevin_Lelouch is being attacked by [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, and [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder].
Turn 11: Kevin_Lelouch
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Prophet of Kruphix].
Turn 12: Garyer99
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Garyer99 casts [Grave Betrayal].
Kevin_Lelouch is being attacked by [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, [Rat] token, and [Kothophed, Soul Hoarder].
Garyer99 casts [Key to the City].
Garyer99 casts [Seedguide Ash].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Horde of Notions].
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Verdant Sun's Avatar] onto the stack (Whenever Verdant Sun's Avatar or another creature enters the battlefield under your control, you g...).
Turn 12: Kevin_Lelouch
Garyer99 puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
Garyer99 draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability.
Kevin_Lelouch plays [Forest].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Trace of Abundance] targeting [Island].
Kevin_Lelouch casts [Ever After] targeting [Elvish Harbinger], and [Shinewend].
[CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Ever After[sU] has a Unclassified bug.  There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves.
Kevin_Lelouch puts [Ever After] on the bottom of the library.
Kevin_Lelouch puts triggered ability from [Elvish Harbinger] onto the stack (When Elvish Harbinger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for an Elf card, reveal ...).
Kevin_Lelouch fails to find a Elf card.
Garyer99 is being attacked by [Horde of Notions], [Prophet of Kruphix], [Seed Guardian], [Elemental] token, and [Rubblehulk].
[Rat] token blocks [Rubblehulk].
[Baleful Force] blocks [Horde of Notions].
[Mitotic Slime] blocks [Elemental] token.
[Rat] token blocks [Seed Guardian].
Kevin_Lelouch has conceded from the game.
Winner: Garyer99
Game 1 Completed.