PennyDreadfulCommander Penny Dreadful EDH BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Back_Alley_G,NotASemicirce,truehero17 == Game 1 (568472170) == PDBot has started watching. [CHAT] NotASemicirce: hi [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: hey truehero17 chooses to play first. truehero17 chooses [Sol'kanar the Swamp King] as their commander. NotASemicirce chooses [Teneb, the Harvester] as their commander. Back_Alley_G chooses [Padeem, Consul of Innovation] as their commander. truehero17 mulligans to 7 cards. NotASemicirce mulligans to 7 cards. [CHAT] truehero17: yeah sorry, had to check on something Back_Alley_G keeps this hand. [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: no big deal truehero17 keeps this hand. NotASemicirce keeps this hand. truehero17 plays [Vivid Creek]. [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Vivid Creek[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. Turn 1: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce plays [Selesnya Guildgate]. Turn 1: Back_Alley_G. [CHAT] truehero17: This is an older list Back_Alley_G plays [Island]. [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: ok Turn 2: truehero17. [CHAT] truehero17: HAve'nt updated my mana base, but most of cards are still good truehero17 plays [Island]. Turn 2: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce plays [Forest]. NotASemicirce casts [Satyr Wayfinder]. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...). NotASemicirce reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Swamp], [Honored Hydra], [Vigor Mortis], and [Gather the Pack]. NotASemicirce puts [Swamp] into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability. NotASemicirce puts [Honored Hydra], [Vigor Mortis], and [Gather the Pack] into their graveyard.. Turn 2: Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G plays [Island]. Turn 3: truehero17. truehero17 plays [Swamp]. Turn 3: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce plays [Swamp]. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder]. NotASemicirce casts [Nyx Weaver]. Turn 3: Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G plays [Foundry of the Consuls]. Back_Alley_G casts [Strata Scythe]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Strata Scythe] onto the stack (When Strata Scythe enters the battlefield, search your library for a land card, exile it, then shu...). truehero17 casts [Dimir Charm] targeting truehero17 (Look at the top three cards of target player's library, then put one back and the rest into that p...). truehero17 put a card on top of their library. Turn 4: truehero17. truehero17 plays [Evolving Wilds]. [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Evolving Wilds[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. truehero17 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card and put it onto the battlefield tapped. Then shuffle yo...). Turn 4: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Nyx Weaver] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, put the top 2 cards of your library into your graveyard.). truehero17 is being attacked by [Nyx Weaver]. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Satyr Wayfinder]. NotASemicirce plays [Swamp]. NotASemicirce exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability. NotASemicirce activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}). Turn 4: Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G plays [Island]. Back_Alley_G casts [Padeem, Consul of Innovation]. Turn 5: truehero17. truehero17 plays [Island]. Turn 5: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Nyx Weaver] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, put the top 2 cards of your library into your graveyard.). NotASemicirce plays [Forest]. NotASemicirce casts [Grapple with the Past]. NotASemicirce returns [Rogue's Passage] to its owner's hand with [Grapple with the Past]. NotASemicirce casts [Millikin]. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Honored Hydra]. Turn 5: Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Padeem, Consul of Innovation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if you control the artifact with the highest converted mana cost ...). Back_Alley_G draws a card with [Padeem, Consul of Innovation]'s ability. Back_Alley_G casts [Pyramid of the Pantheon]. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Strata Scythe] targeting [Padeem, Consul of Innovation] (Equip {3}). Turn 6: truehero17. truehero17 plays [Island]. truehero17 casts [Bloodwater Entity]. truehero17 puts triggered ability from [Bloodwater Entity] onto the stack targeting [Dimir Charm] (When Bloodwater Entity enters the battlefield, you may put target instant or sorcery card from you...). Turn 6: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Nyx Weaver] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, put the top 2 cards of your library into your graveyard.). NotASemicirce plays [Swamp]. NotASemicirce exiles [Nyx Weaver] with [Nyx Weaver]'s ability. NotASemicirce activates an ability of [Nyx Weaver] targeting [Vigor Mortis] ( Return target card from your graveyard to your hand.). NotASemicirce returns [Vigor Mortis] to its owner's hand with [Nyx Weaver]'s ability. NotASemicirce puts [Commune with the Gods] into their graveyard with with [Millikin]'s ability. NotASemicirce casts [Vigor Mortis] (with {G}) targeting [Verdant Force]. NotASemicirce returns [Verdant Force] to the battlefield with [Vigor Mortis]'s ability truehero17 is being attacked by [Honored Hydra]. [Bloodwater Entity] blocks [Honored Hydra]. Turn 6: Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Padeem, Consul of Innovation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if you control the artifact with the highest converted mana cost ...). NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Verdant Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, create a 1/1 green Saproling creature token.). NotASemicirce's [Verdant Force] creates a Saproling token. Back_Alley_G draws a card with [Padeem, Consul of Innovation]'s ability. Back_Alley_G plays [Island]. Back_Alley_G casts [Curse of the Swine] targeting [Verdant Force], and [Honored Hydra]. (X is 2). truehero17 casts [Twincast] targeting [Curse of the Swine]. truehero17 puts a copy of [Curse of the Swine] on the stack. truehero17 changes targets of [Curse of the Swine] to [Padeem, Consul of Innovation], and [Millikin]. truehero17's [Curse of the Swine] creates a Boar token under Back_Alley_G's control. truehero17's [Curse of the Swine] creates a Boar token under NotASemicirce's control. Back_Alley_G's [Curse of the Swine] creates a Boar token under NotASemicirce's control. Back_Alley_G's [Curse of the Swine] creates a Boar token under NotASemicirce's control. Turn 7: truehero17. [CHAT] NotASemicirce: to an extent I had this coming truehero17 casts [Dimir Signet]. truehero17 casts [Deny Reality] targeting [Boar] token. truehero17 puts triggered ability from [Deny Reality] onto the stack (Cascade). truehero17 casts [Heat Shimmer] targeting [Satyr Wayfinder]. truehero17 puts triggered ability from [Satyr Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Satyr Wayfinder enters the battlefield, reveal the top four cards of your library. You may pu...). truehero17 reveals 4 cards with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability: [Skyscribing], [Swamp], [Reign of the Pit], and [Melek, Izzet Paragon]. truehero17 puts [Swamp] into their hand with with [Satyr Wayfinder]'s ability. truehero17 puts [Skyscribing], [Reign of the Pit], and [Melek, Izzet Paragon] into their graveyard.. truehero17 returns [Boar] token to its owner's hand with [Deny Reality]. truehero17 plays [Swamp]. truehero17 puts triggered ability from [Heat Shimmer] onto the stack (Exile Satyr Wayfinder at the beginning of the end step.). Turn 7: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce plays [Rogue's Passage]. truehero17 is being attacked by [Boar] token and [Boar] token. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Boar] token, [Saproling] token, and [Satyr Wayfinder]. NotASemicirce casts [Moldgraf Monstrosity]. Turn 7: Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G plays [Island]. Back_Alley_G casts [Ur-Golem's Eye]. [CHAT] truehero17: CAsual 8/8 that does stuff Back_Alley_G casts [Clone]. Turn 8: truehero17. truehero17 plays [Mountain]. truehero17 casts [Mystic Retrieval] from the graveyard targeting [Reign of the Pit]. truehero17 returns [Reign of the Pit] to its owner's hand with [Mystic Retrieval]. [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Mystic Retrieval[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [sG]In order to prevent further spamming, I'll stop warning you now. [sG]For more information about Penny Dreadful, see pdmtgo.com or reddit.com/r/PennyDreadfulMTG truehero17 casts [Reign of the Pit]. NotASemicirce sacrifices [Satyr Wayfinder]. Back_Alley_G sacrifices [Moldgraf Monstrosity]. truehero17's [Reign of the Pit] creates a Demon token. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Moldgraf Monstrosity] onto the stack (When Moldgraf Monstrosity dies, exile it, then return two creature cards at random from your grave...). Turn 8: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce plays [Plains]. [CHAT] truehero17: Need to put this through the deck checker later NotASemicirce casts [Baleful Force]. Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Moldgraf Monstrosity], [Boar] token, [Boar] token, [Boar] token, and [Saproling] token. Turn 8: Back_Alley_G. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.). NotASemicirce draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability. Turn 9: truehero17. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.). NotASemicirce draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability. truehero17 plays [Dismal Backwater]. truehero17 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). truehero17 casts [Rise from the Tides]. truehero17's [Rise from the Tides] creates six Zombie tokens. Turn 9: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.). NotASemicirce draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability. NotASemicirce plays [Swamp]. NotASemicirce casts [Whip of Erebos]. NotASemicirce casts [Corpse Connoisseur]. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Corpse Connoisseur] onto the stack (When Corpse Connoisseur enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a creature card an...). truehero17 is being attacked by [Baleful Force], [Moldgraf Monstrosity], [Boar] token, [Boar] token, [Boar] token, and [Saproling] token. truehero17 casts [Dimir Charm] targeting truehero17 (Look at the top three cards of target player's library, then put one back and the rest into that p...). truehero17 put a card on top of their library. Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Foundry of the Consuls] ( Create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature tokens with flying.). Back_Alley_G's [Foundry of the Consuls] creates two Thopter tokens. Turn 9: Back_Alley_G. NotASemicirce puts triggered ability from [Baleful Force] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.). NotASemicirce draws a card with [Baleful Force]'s ability. Back_Alley_G casts [Phyrexian Ingester]. Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Ingester] onto the stack targeting [Baleful Force] (When Phyrexian Ingester enters the battlefield, you may exile target nontoken creature.). Turn 10: truehero17. truehero17 plays [Swamp]. truehero17 casts [Galvanoth]. NotASemicirce is being attacked by [Demon] token. Turn 10: NotASemicirce. NotASemicirce plays [Svogthos, the Restless Tomb]. truehero17 is being attacked by [Corpse Connoisseur], [Moldgraf Monstrosity], [Boar] token, [Boar] token, and [Boar] token. truehero17 is now a watcher. NotASemicirce puts [Brawn], [Plains], [Plains], and [Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts] into their graveyard with with [Rot Farm Skeleton]'s ability. NotASemicirce activates an ability of [Rot Farm Skeleton] ( Return Rot Farm Skeleton from your graveyard to the battlefield.). NotASemicirce casts [Breath of Life] targeting [Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts]. NotASemicirce returns [Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts] to the battlefield with [Breath of Life]'s ability Turn 10: Back_Alley_G. [CHAT] truehero17: Whelming wave off the top Back_Alley_G casts [Compulsive Research] targeting Back_Alley_G. Back_Alley_G draws three cards with [Compulsive Research]. Back_Alley_G discards [Island]. Back_Alley_G plays [Tomb of the Spirit Dragon]. Back_Alley_G has conceded from the game. Winner: NotASemicirce Game 1 Completed. Back_Alley_G has left the game.