PennyDreadful PD BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality jmanjohan,Jeff213 == Game 1 (566429480) == PDBot has started watching. jmanjohan joined the game. [CHAT] PDBot: [sD]If this is a league game, don't forget to report! Jeff213 chooses to play first. Jeff213 keeps this hand. [CHAT] jmanjohan: This isn't a league, right? jmanjohan keeps this hand. Jeff213 skips their draw step. [CHAT] Jeff213: sure doesnt matter to me Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Turn 1: jmanjohan. [CHAT] jmanjohan: Oh. well I'd love for it to be a league match [CHAT] Jeff213: we can report it if you want i dont care [CHAT] Jeff213: this deck is league [CHAT] jmanjohan: sweet [CHAT] Jeff213: idk how to report though jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Carnophage]. Turn 2: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Jeff213 casts [Auratog]. Turn 2: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). [CHAT] jmanjohan: its easy. go to the same place you went to sign up for the league and theres a tap that says 'report" jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Carnophage]. jmanjohan casts [Highborn Ghoul]. Turn 3: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 casts [Mesa Enchantress]. Turn 3: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Highborn Ghoul] and [Carnophage]. jmanjohan casts [Ulcerate] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. jmanjohan casts [Blood Scrivener]. Turn 4: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. Jeff213 casts [Orzhov Signet]. Turn 4: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Cemetery Reaper]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Blood Scrivener], [Highborn Ghoul], and [Carnophage]. Turn 5: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. [CHAT] Jeff213: beat down Jeff213 casts [Parallax Wave]. [CHAT] Jeff213: good thing i have that Turn 5: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). Jeff213 is being attacked by [Cemetery Reaper], [Blood Scrivener], [Highborn Ghoul], and [Carnophage]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Cemetery Reaper] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Blood Scrivener] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Highborn Ghoul] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Carnophage] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (When Parallax Wave leaves the battlefield, each player returns to the battlefield all cards he or ...). jmanjohan casts [Carnophage]. jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Turn 6: Jeff213. Jeff213 casts [Parallax Wave]. Turn 6: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Carnophage]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Carnophage] ( Exile target creature.). Turn 7: Jeff213. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). Jeff213 casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). Jeff213 casts [Monk Idealist]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Monk Idealist] onto the stack targeting [Parallax Wave] (When Monk Idealist enters the battlefield, return target enchantment card from your graveyard to y...). Jeff213 returns [Parallax Wave] to its owner's hand with [Monk Idealist]'s ability. jmanjohan is being attacked by [Auratog]. Turn 7: jmanjohan. jmanjohan casts [Liliana's Mastery]. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Liliana's Mastery] onto the stack (When Liliana's Mastery enters the battlefield, create two 2/2 black Zombie creature tokens.). jmanjohan's [Liliana's Mastery] creates two Zombie tokens. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Monk Idealist] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Mesa Enchantress] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Zombie] token ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (When Parallax Wave leaves the battlefield, each player returns to the battlefield all cards he or ...). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Monk Idealist] onto the stack targeting [Parallax Wave] (When Monk Idealist enters the battlefield, return target enchantment card from your graveyard to y...). Jeff213 returns [Parallax Wave] to its owner's hand with [Monk Idealist]'s ability. Turn 8: Jeff213. Jeff213 casts [Parallax Wave]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. Jeff213 plays [Forsaken Sanctuary]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Zombie] token ( Exile target creature.). Turn 8: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Monk Idealist] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Carnophage] ( Exile target creature.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (When Parallax Wave leaves the battlefield, each player returns to the battlefield all cards he or ...). jmanjohan casts [Grasp of Darkness] targeting [Auratog]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Monk Idealist] onto the stack targeting [Animate Dead] (When Monk Idealist enters the battlefield, return target enchantment card from your graveyard to y...). Jeff213 returns [Animate Dead] to its owner's hand with [Monk Idealist]'s ability. Turn 9: Jeff213. Jeff213 casts [Auratog]. jmanjohan has conceded from the game. Winner: Jeff213 Game 1 Completed. jmanjohan has left the game. == Game 2 (566431468) == PDBot has started watching. [CHAT] Jeff213: sigh [CHAT] Jeff213: this is already over Jeff213 mulligans to 4 cards. Jeff213 keeps this hand. Jeff213 put a card on the bottom of the library. jmanjohan skips their draw step. jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Turn 1: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Turn 2: jmanjohan. jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Blood Scrivener]. Turn 2: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. Turn 3: jmanjohan. jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Lord of the Accursed]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Blood Scrivener]. Turn 3: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Forsaken Sanctuary]. Turn 4: jmanjohan. jmanjohan casts [Distress] targeting Jeff213. Jeff213 discards [Parallax Wave]. Jeff213 reveals their hand to [Distress], containing [Animate Dead], [Mesa Enchantress], and [Monk Idealist]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Lord of the Accursed] and [Blood Scrivener]. Turn 4: Jeff213. Jeff213 casts [Monk Idealist]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Monk Idealist] onto the stack targeting [Parallax Wave] (When Monk Idealist enters the battlefield, return target enchantment card from your graveyard to y...). jmanjohan casts [Ulcerate] targeting [Monk Idealist]. Jeff213 returns [Parallax Wave] to its owner's hand with [Monk Idealist]'s ability. Turn 5: jmanjohan. jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Memoricide] targeting Jeff213. jmanjohan names Parallax Wave for [Memoricide]. Turn 5: Jeff213. [CHAT] jmanjohan: oops Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Jeff213 has conceded from the game. Winner: jmanjohan Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (566432176) == PDBot has started watching. Turn 3: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. Jeff213 casts [Orzhov Signet]. Jeff213 casts [Brain Maggot]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting jmanjohan (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...). [CHAT] jmanjohan: lol jmanjohan reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Swamp], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Swamp], and [Swamp]. jmanjohan reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Swamp], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Swamp], and [Swamp]. [CHAT] Jeff213: ok then Turn 3: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Carnophage]. jmanjohan casts [Diregraf Ghoul]. [CHAT] jmanjohan: my tech against brain maggot is not have only lands Turn 4: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Jeff213 casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Auratog]. Turn 4: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Diregraf Ghoul] and [Carnophage]. [CHAT] Jeff213: seemed to work alright to me ;p [Auratog] blocks [Diregraf Ghoul]. [Brain Maggot] blocks [Carnophage]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). jmanjohan activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Jeff213 ( Target player exiles a card from his or her graveyard.). Jeff213 exiles [Brain Maggot]. Turn 5: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Swamp]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Spirit Loop] targeting [Auratog]. Turn 5: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Carnophage]. [Auratog] blocks [Carnophage]. [CHAT] Jeff213: er [CHAT] Jeff213: i messed that up [CHAT] Jeff213: lol [CHAT] Jeff213: thats game [CHAT] Jeff213: im still not used to mtgo interface Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Spirit Loop] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage, you gain that much life.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Spirit Loop] onto the stack (When Spirit Loop is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, return Spirit Loop to its owner's h...). jmanjohan activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Jeff213 ( Target player exiles a card from his or her graveyard.). Jeff213 exiles [Spirit Loop]. jmanjohan activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting [Auratog] ( Exile target card from a graveyard. Draw a card.). jmanjohan draws a card with [Scrabbling Claws]'s ability. jmanjohan casts [Diregraf Ghoul]. [CHAT] jmanjohan: bummer jmanjohan casts [Cemetery Reaper]. Turn 6: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Auratog]. Jeff213 casts [Underworld Coinsmith]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Underworld Coinsmith] onto the stack (Whenever Underworld Coinsmith or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, yo...). Turn 6: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Memoricide] targeting Jeff213. jmanjohan names Parallax Wave for [Memoricide]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Diregraf Ghoul] and [Carnophage]. [Auratog] blocks [Diregraf Ghoul]. [Underworld Coinsmith] blocks [Carnophage]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Turn 7: Jeff213. Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Underworld Coinsmith]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Underworld Coinsmith] onto the stack (Whenever Underworld Coinsmith or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, yo...). Jeff213 casts [Spirit Loop] targeting [Auratog]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Underworld Coinsmith] onto the stack (Whenever Underworld Coinsmith or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, yo...). Turn 7: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. jmanjohan casts [Highborn Ghoul]. Turn 8: Jeff213. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Brain Maggot]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Underworld Coinsmith] onto the stack (Whenever Underworld Coinsmith or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, yo...). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting jmanjohan (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...). jmanjohan reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Swamp]. jmanjohan reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Swamp]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When this leaves the battlefield, the enchanted creature's controller sacrifices it.). Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Jeff213 casts [Monk Idealist]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Monk Idealist] onto the stack targeting [Underworld Coinsmith] (When Monk Idealist enters the battlefield, return target enchantment card from your graveyard to y...). jmanjohan activates an ability of [Cemetery Reaper] targeting [Underworld Coinsmith] ( Exile target creature card from a graveyard. Create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.). jmanjohan's [Cemetery Reaper] creates a Zombie token. Jeff213's Triggered ability from Monk Idealist is countered because it has no legal targets. Jeff213 plays [Plains]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Auratog] ( Auratog gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Spirit Loop] onto the stack (When Spirit Loop is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, return Spirit Loop to its owner's h...). Jeff213 casts [Spirit Loop] targeting [Auratog]. OneSwellFoop has started watching. jmanjohan is being attacked by [Auratog]. [Zombie] token blocks [Auratog]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Spirit Loop] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage, you gain that much life.). Turn 8: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jmanjohan casts [Blood Scrivener]. jmanjohan plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 is being attacked by [Highborn Ghoul] and [Carnophage]. [Brain Maggot] blocks [Highborn Ghoul]. Turn 9: Jeff213. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Cemetery Reaper]. jmanjohan activates an ability of [Cemetery Reaper] targeting [Brain Maggot] ( Exile target creature card from a graveyard. Create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.). jmanjohan's [Cemetery Reaper] creates a Zombie token. Jeff213 casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. Turn 9: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). Replacement effect from Blood Scrivener causes jmanjohan to draw two cards and lose 1 life jmanjohan casts [Diregraf Ghoul]. jmanjohan casts [Lord of the Accursed]. Turn 10: Jeff213. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [CHAT] Jeff213: dont think i have any answer Jeff213 plays [Swamp]. Jeff213 casts [Auratog]. Jeff213 casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Orzhov Guildgate]. Jeff213 activates an ability of [Orzhov Guildgate] ( Draw a card.). Jeff213 draws a card with [Orzhov Guildgate]'s ability. Jeff213 casts [Underworld Coinsmith]. Jeff213 puts triggered ability from [Underworld Coinsmith] onto the stack (Whenever Underworld Coinsmith or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, yo...). Turn 10: jmanjohan. jmanjohan puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). Replacement effect from Blood Scrivener causes jmanjohan to draw two cards and lose 1 life jmanjohan casts [Cemetery Reaper]. jmanjohan activates an ability of [Lord of the Accursed] ( All Zombies gain menace until end of turn.). Jeff213 is being attacked by [Diregraf Ghoul], [Zombie] token, [Blood Scrivener], [Highborn Ghoul], and [Carnophage]. [CHAT] Jeff213: gg [CHAT] jmanjohan: gg Jeff213 has conceded from the game. Winner: jmanjohan Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: jmanjohan: 2–1