PennyDreadful Penny Dreadful Casual BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality stash86,jjhettich == Game 1 (564099728) == PDBot has started watching. stash86 joined the game. [CHAT] jjhettich: hello gl hf jjhettich chooses to play first. jjhettich mulligans to 6 cards. stash86 keeps this hand. jjhettich mulligans to 5 cards. jjhettich keeps this hand. [CHAT] stash86: hi gl hf jjhettich put a card on top of jjhettich's library. jjhettich skips their draw step. jjhettich plays [Mountain]. Turn 1: stash86. stash86 plays [Swamp]. Turn 2: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Mountain]. Turn 2: stash86. stash86 plays [Swamp]. stash86 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting jjhettich. littlefield has started watching. jjhettich discards [Chain Lightning]. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Desert of the Fervent], [Astral Slide], and [Astral Slide]. jjhettich discards [Desert of the Fervent]. jjhettich cycles [Desert of the Fervent]. Turn 3: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Plains]. jjhettich casts [Astral Slide]. Turn 3: stash86. stash86 plays [Swamp]. stash86 casts [Mortician Beetle]. stash86 casts [Pain Seer]. Turn 4: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Mountain]. jjhettich casts [Astral Slide]. Turn 4: stash86. jjhettich is being attacked by [Pain Seer] and [Mortician Beetle]. stash86 casts [Nantuko Shade]. Turn 5: jjhettich. jjhettich casts [Lightning Rift]. Turn 5: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Pain Seer] onto the stack (Whenever Pain Seer becomes untapped, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into yo...). stash86 reveals [Swamp] with [Pain Seer]'s ability. stash86 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting jjhettich. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Desert of the True]. stash86 plays [Swamp]. stash86 casts [Pain Seer]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Nantuko Shade], [Pain Seer], and [Mortician Beetle]. Turn 6: jjhettich. Turn 6: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Pain Seer] onto the stack (Whenever Pain Seer becomes untapped, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into yo...). stash86 reveals [Swamp] with [Pain Seer]'s ability. stash86 plays [Swamp]. stash86 casts [Brain Maggot]. jjhettich discards [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich cycles [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Pain Seer] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Pain Seer] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack ( When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature...). stash86 puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting jjhettich (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...). jjhettich reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [End Hostilities] and [Desert of the True]. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Desert of the True]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Mortician Beetle]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Nantuko Shade to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Pain Seer to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end ste...). Turn 7: jjhettich. Turn 7: stash86. stash86 casts [Tormented Hero]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Nantuko Shade], [Pain Seer], [Brain Maggot], and [Mortician Beetle]. littlefield has stopped watching. jjhettich discards [Inferno Jet]. jjhettich cycles [Inferno Jet]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Pain Seer] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Brain Maggot] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). stash86 casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting jjhettich. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Nantuko Shade to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Pain Seer to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end ste...). Turn 8: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Plains]. jjhettich casts [End Hostilities]. Turn 8: stash86. stash86 casts [Blood Scrivener]. stash86 has conceded from the game. Winner: jjhettich Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (564100348) == PDBot has started watching. jjhettich plays [Cloudpost]. Turn 3: stash86. stash86 casts [Brain Maggot]. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting jjhettich (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...). jjhettich reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [End Hostilities], [Renewed Faith], [End Hostilities], and [Gideon's Intervention]. [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Gideon's Intervention[sU] has a Unclassified bug. does not prevent damage from Syndicate trafficker's +1/+1 counters. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [End Hostilities], [End Hostilities], and [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Brain Maggot] and [Tormented Hero]. Turn 3: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Plains]. Turn 4: stash86. stash86 casts [Brain Maggot]. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting jjhettich (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...). jjhettich reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [End Hostilities], [End Hostilities], and [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [End Hostilities] and [End Hostilities]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Brain Maggot], [Brain Maggot], and [Tormented Hero]. Turn 4: jjhettich. Turn 5: stash86. stash86 casts [Tormented Hero]. stash86 casts [Mortician Beetle]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Brain Maggot], [Brain Maggot], [Brain Maggot], and [Tormented Hero]. Turn 5: jjhettich. jjhettich has conceded from the game. Winner: stash86 Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (564100554) == PDBot has started watching. stash86 casts [Carnophage]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage]. Turn 3: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Plains]. Turn 3: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). stash86 casts [Mortician Beetle]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage] and [Carnophage]. Turn 4: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Mountain]. jjhettich discards [Slice and Dice]. jjhettich cycles [Slice and Dice]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Carnophage] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Slice and Dice] onto the stack ( When you cycle Slice and Dice, you may have it deal 1 damage to each creature.). Turn 4: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). stash86 casts [Tormented Hero]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage]. Turn 5: jjhettich. jjhettich casts [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich names Brain Maggot for [Gideon's Intervention]. Turn 5: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). stash86 plays [Swamp]. stash86 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting jjhettich. jjhettich discards [End Hostilities]. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Astral Slide], [Astral Slide], [Decree of Justice], and [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Tormented Hero] and [Carnophage]. Turn 6: jjhettich. jjhettich discards [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich cycles [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Tormented Hero] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack ( When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature...). jjhettich plays [Mountain]. Turn 6: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). stash86 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting jjhettich. jjhettich discards [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Astral Slide], [Astral Slide], and [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage]. Turn 7: jjhettich. jjhettich casts [Astral Slide]. Turn 7: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage]. jjhettich discards [Desert of the Fervent]. jjhettich cycles [Desert of the Fervent]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Carnophage] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Carnophage] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). stash86 casts [Black Knight]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Carnophage to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end st...). Turn 8: jjhettich. Turn 8: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). stash86 plays [Swamp]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage] and [Black Knight]. jjhettich discards [Renewed Faith]. jjhettich cycles [Renewed Faith]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Black Knight] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Carnophage] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Renewed Faith] onto the stack ( When you cycle Renewed Faith, you may gain 2 life.). stash86 casts [Nantuko Shade]. stash86 casts [Mortician Beetle]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Carnophage to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end st...). Turn 9: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Mountain]. jjhettich casts [Lightning Rift]. Turn 9: stash86. stash86 puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.). jjhettich is being attacked by [Carnophage], [Mortician Beetle], and [Nantuko Shade]. jjhettich discards [Desert of the Fervent]. jjhettich cycles [Desert of the Fervent]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Mortician Beetle] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Carnophage] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). stash86 casts [Nantuko Shade]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Nantuko Shade to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end...). Turn 10: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Plains]. jjhettich casts [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich names Nantuko Shade for [Gideon's Intervention]. jjhettich casts [Astral Slide]. Turn 10: stash86. stash86 plays [Swamp]. stash86 casts [Blood Scrivener]. stash86 casts [Blood Scrivener]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Nantuko Shade] and [Nantuko Shade]. Turn 11: jjhettich. jjhettich plays [Plains]. jjhettich discards [Starstorm]. jjhettich cycles [Starstorm]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Blood Scrivener] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting [Blood Scrivener] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich chooses not to use [Astral Slide]'s ability. jjhettich chooses not to use [Astral Slide]'s ability. Turn 11: stash86. stash86 casts [Pain Seer]. Turn 12: jjhettich. jjhettich discards [Solar Blast]. jjhettich cycles [Solar Blast]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting stash86 (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting stash86 (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Nantuko Shade] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Solar Blast] onto the stack targeting [Pain Seer] ( When you cycle Solar Blast, you may have it deal 1 damage to target creature or player.). jjhettich chooses not to use [Astral Slide]'s ability. jjhettich chooses not to use [Astral Slide]'s ability. jjhettich plays [Mountain]. Turn 12: stash86. stash86 plays [Swamp]. jjhettich is being attacked by [Pain Seer], [Nantuko Shade], and [Nantuko Shade]. stash86 activates an ability of [Nantuko Shade] ( Nantuko Shade gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). stash86 activates an ability of [Nantuko Shade] ( Nantuko Shade gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). stash86 activates an ability of [Nantuko Shade] ( Nantuko Shade gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). stash86 activates an ability of [Nantuko Shade] ( Nantuko Shade gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). stash86 activates an ability of [Nantuko Shade] ( Nantuko Shade gets +1/+1 until end of turn.). Turn 13: jjhettich. jjhettich casts [End Hostilities]. jjhettich casts [Lightning Rift]. Turn 13: stash86. stash86 casts [Tormented Hero]. Turn 14: jjhettich. Turn 14: stash86. jjhettich discards [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich cycles [Decree of Justice]. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting stash86 (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting stash86 (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Lightning Rift] onto the stack targeting stash86 (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may pay {1}. If you do, Lightning Rift deals 2 damage to targ...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Tormented Hero] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Tormented Hero] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...). jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack ( When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature...). jjhettich's [Decree of Justice] creates three Soldier tokens. jjhettich's Triggered ability from Astral Slide is countered because it has no legal targets. jjhettich puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Tormented Hero to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next en...). Turn 15: jjhettich. stash86 is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token. [CHAT] stash86: ggs Winner: jjhettich Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: jjhettich: 2–1