PennyDreadful
Penny Dreadful
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
BigM,Athar

== Game 1 (553348398) ==
PDBot has started watching.
Athar joined the game.
[CHAT] BigM: hi there
[CHAT] BigM: gl hf
Athar chooses to play first.
Athar mulligans to 6 cards.
BigM mulligans to 6 cards.
Athar keeps this hand.
BigM mulligans to 5 cards.
BigM keeps this hand.
[CHAT] Athar: you too
Athar put a card on top of Athar's library.
BigM put a card on the bottom of the library.
Athar skips their draw step.
Athar plays [Arcane Sanctum].
Turn 1: BigM.
BigM plays [Island].
Turn 2: Athar.
Athar plays [Plains].
[CHAT] BigM: this might get really awkward over here
Turn 2: BigM.
BigM plays [Forest].
BigM casts [Looter il-Kor].
[CHAT] Athar: why?
Turn 3: Athar.
[CHAT] BigM: hand is sketchy
Athar plays [Plains].
[CHAT] Athar: eh, my land colors arent great either...
Athar casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Looter il-Kor].
Turn 3: BigM.
BigM casts [Grapple with the Past].
BigM returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with [Grapple with the Past].
BigM plays [Forest].
BigM casts [Vessel of Nascency].
Turn 4: Athar.
Turn 4: BigM.
BigM activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
BigM reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Forest], [Vessel of Nascency], [Simic Guildgate], and [Advanced Stitchwing].
BigM puts [Vessel of Nascency] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
BigM puts [Forest], [Simic Guildgate], and [Advanced Stitchwing] into their graveyard..
BigM plays [Forest].
BigM casts [Vessel of Nascency].
Athar casts [Azorius Charm] (Draw a card.).
Athar draws a card with [Azorius Charm].
Turn 5: Athar.
Athar plays [Island].
Turn 5: BigM.
BigM plays [Island].
Turn 6: Athar.
Athar plays [Azorius Guildgate].
BigM discards [Honored Hydra].
BigM discards [Advanced Stitchwing].
BigM activates an ability of [Advanced Stitchwing] ( Return Advanced Stitchwing from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
BigM activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
BigM reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Grapple with the Past], [Revolutionary Rebuff], [Wharf Infiltrator], and [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM puts [Wharf Infiltrator] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
BigM puts [Grapple with the Past], [Revolutionary Rebuff], and [Stitchwing Skaab] into their graveyard..
Turn 6: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing].
Turn 7: Athar.
Turn 7: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing].
Turn 8: Athar.
Athar plays [Dimir Guildgate].
BigM discards [Honored Hydra].
BigM discards [Wharf Infiltrator].
BigM activates an ability of [Advanced Stitchwing] ( Return Advanced Stitchwing from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 8: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing] and [Advanced Stitchwing].
BigM casts [Treasure Cruise].
Athar casts [Dissolve] targeting [Treasure Cruise].
BigM casts [Revolutionary Rebuff] targeting [Dissolve].
[CHAT] BigM: I'm an idiot
Athar put a card on top of Athar's library.
[CHAT] BigM: !punt
[CHAT] PDBot: Unknown Command
Turn 9: Athar.
Athar plays [Blighted Fen].
Athar casts [Planar Outburst].
Turn 9: BigM.
BigM casts [Treasure Cruise].
BigM draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
BigM plays [Evolving Wilds].
BigM casts [Carven Caryatid].
BigM puts triggered ability from [Carven Caryatid] onto the stack (When Carven Caryatid enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
BigM draws a card with [Carven Caryatid]'s ability.
Turn 10: Athar.
Athar casts [Approach of the Second Sun].
Athar puts [Approach of the Second Sun] beneath the top 6 cards of their library.
BigM activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card and put it onto the battlefield tapped. Then shuffle yo...).
Turn 10: BigM.
BigM plays [Forest].
BigM exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability.
BigM activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}).
Turn 11: Athar.
Athar plays [Island].
Athar casts [Hero's Downfall] targeting [Honored Hydra].
BigM discards [Looter il-Kor].
BigM discards [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Hero's Downfall].
Athar casts [Forbid] targeting [Forbid].
Turn 11: BigM.
BigM casts [Wharf Infiltrator].
BigM exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability.
BigM activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}).
Turn 12: Athar.
Athar plays [Arcane Sanctum].
Athar casts [Hero's Downfall] targeting [Honored Hydra].
Turn 12: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Wharf Infiltrator].
BigM puts triggered ability from [Wharf Infiltrator] onto the stack (Whenever Wharf Infiltrator deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card. If you do, discar...).
BigM draws a card with [Wharf Infiltrator]'s ability.
BigM discards [Wonder].
BigM puts triggered ability from [Wharf Infiltrator] onto the stack (Whenever you discard a creature card, you may pay {2}. If you do, create a 3/2 colorless Eldrazi H...).
BigM's [Wharf Infiltrator] creates an Eldrazi Horror token.
Turn 13: Athar.
Athar plays [Azorius Guildgate].
Turn 13: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Eldrazi Horror] token and [Wharf Infiltrator].
Athar casts [Quicken].
Athar draws a card with [Quicken].
Athar casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Wharf Infiltrator].
Turn 14: Athar.
BigM discards [Simic Guildgate].
BigM discards [Island].
BigM activates an ability of [Advanced Stitchwing] ( Return Advanced Stitchwing from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 14: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing] and [Eldrazi Horror] token.
Athar activates an ability of [Blighted Fen] targeting BigM ( Target opponent sacrifices a creature.).
BigM sacrifices [Carven Caryatid].
Turn 15: Athar.
[CHAT] BigM: approach is next now, right?
BigM casts [Catalog].
BigM draws two cards with [Catalog].
[CHAT] Athar: i think so
BigM discards [Carven Caryatid].
Turn 15: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing] and [Eldrazi Horror] token.
Winner: BigM
Game 1 Completed.
Athar has left the game.

== Game 2 (553351516) ==
PDBot has started watching.
Athar chooses to play first.
Athar keeps this hand.
BigM keeps this hand.
Athar skips their draw step.
Athar plays [Arcane Sanctum].
Turn 1: BigM.
BigM plays [Simic Guildgate].
Turn 2: Athar.
Athar plays [Plains].
Turn 2: BigM.
BigM plays [Forest].
BigM casts [Wharf Infiltrator].
Athar casts [Power Sink] targeting [Wharf Infiltrator]. (X is 1).
Turn 3: Athar.
Athar plays [Azorius Guildgate].
Turn 3: BigM.
BigM casts [Looter il-Kor].
BigM plays [Simic Guildgate].
Athar casts [Anticipate].
Turn 4: Athar.
Athar plays [Dimir Guildgate].
Turn 4: BigM.
BigM plays [Island].
Athar is being attacked by [Looter il-Kor].
BigM puts triggered ability from [Looter il-Kor] onto the stack ( Whenever Looter il-Kor deals damage to an opponent, draw a card, then discard a card.).
BigM draws a card with [Looter il-Kor]'s ability.
BigM discards [Evolving Wilds].
BigM casts [Vessel of Nascency].
Turn 5: Athar.
Athar plays [Island].
BigM activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
BigM reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Forbid], [Catalog], [Forest], and [Island].
BigM puts [Forest] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
BigM puts [Forbid], [Catalog], and [Island] into their graveyard..
Turn 5: BigM.
BigM plays [Simic Guildgate].
Athar is being attacked by [Looter il-Kor].
BigM puts triggered ability from [Looter il-Kor] onto the stack ( Whenever Looter il-Kor deals damage to an opponent, draw a card, then discard a card.).
BigM draws a card with [Looter il-Kor]'s ability.
BigM discards [Evolving Wilds].
Athar casts [Jace's Ingenuity].
BigM casts [Revolutionary Rebuff] targeting [Jace's Ingenuity].
Turn 6: Athar.
Turn 6: BigM.
BigM plays [Forest].
Athar casts [Hero's Downfall] targeting [Looter il-Kor].
BigM casts [Honored Hydra].
Turn 7: Athar.
Athar casts [Hero's Downfall] targeting [Honored Hydra].
Turn 7: BigM.
BigM exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability.
BigM activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}).
BigM plays [Forest].
Turn 8: Athar.
Turn 8: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Honored Hydra].
Athar casts [Azorius Charm] targeting [Honored Hydra] (Put target attacking or blocking creature on top of its owner's library.).
BigM casts [Stitchwing Skaab].
Turn 9: Athar.
Athar plays [Island].
Turn 9: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM casts [Vessel of Nascency].
BigM casts [Carven Caryatid].
BigM puts triggered ability from [Carven Caryatid] onto the stack (When Carven Caryatid enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
BigM draws a card with [Carven Caryatid]'s ability.
Athar casts [Away] targeting [Stitchwing Skaab], and BigM (Fuse).
BigM casts [Revolutionary Rebuff] targeting [Far & Away].
Turn 10: Athar.
Athar casts [Treasure Cruise].
Athar draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
Athar plays [Plains].
Turn 10: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
BigM reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Advanced Stitchwing], [Forbid], [Island], and [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM puts [Advanced Stitchwing] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
BigM puts [Forbid], [Island], and [Stitchwing Skaab] into their graveyard..
Turn 11: Athar.
Athar plays [Arcane Sanctum].
BigM discards [Forest].
BigM discards [Island].
BigM activates an ability of [Stitchwing Skaab] ( Return Stitchwing Skaab from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 11: BigM.
BigM casts [Carven Caryatid].
Athar casts [Dissolve] targeting [Carven Caryatid].
Athar put a card on top of Athar's library.
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab] and [Stitchwing Skaab].
Turn 12: Athar.
Athar plays [Vivid Meadow].
Athar casts [Planar Outburst].
BigM discards [Advanced Stitchwing].
BigM discards [Honored Hydra].
BigM activates an ability of [Stitchwing Skaab] ( Return Stitchwing Skaab from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 12: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab].
Athar exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability.
BigM activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}).
Turn 13: Athar.
Athar casts [Planar Outburst].
Turn 13: BigM.
Turn 14: Athar.
Athar casts [Anticipate].
Turn 14: BigM.
BigM casts [Honored Hydra].
Athar casts [Power Sink] targeting [Honored Hydra]. (X is 2).
Turn 15: Athar.
Athar plays [Dimir Guildgate].
Athar casts [Approach of the Second Sun].
Athar puts [Approach of the Second Sun] beneath the top 6 cards of their library.
Turn 15: BigM.
Athar exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability.
BigM activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}).
Turn 16: Athar.
Athar casts [Jace's Ingenuity].
Athar draws three cards with [Jace's Ingenuity].
Athar casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Honored Hydra].
BigM discards [Forest].
BigM discards [Forest].
BigM casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Ultimate Price].
Athar casts [Dissolve] targeting [Forbid].
[CHAT] BigM: I hate getting Forbid countered
Athar put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 16: BigM.
BigM casts [Grapple with the Past].
[CHAT] Athar: yeah
BigM returns [Advanced Stitchwing] to its owner's hand with [Grapple with the Past].
BigM casts [Advanced Stitchwing].
Turn 17: Athar.
Athar casts [Approach of the Second Sun].
[CHAT] BigM: wow that was fast
Winner: Athar
Game 2 Completed.
Athar has left the game.

== Game 3 (553353756) ==
PDBot has started watching.
Turn 2: BigM.
BigM plays [Island].
Turn 2: Athar.
Athar plays [Island].
[CHAT] BigM: 2 draw steps, 3 from jace, 1 from scry
BigM activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
BigM reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Grapple with the Past], [Vessel of Nascency], [Simic Guildgate], and [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM puts [Simic Guildgate] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
BigM puts [Grapple with the Past], [Vessel of Nascency], and [Stitchwing Skaab] into their graveyard..
Turn 3: BigM.
BigM plays [Simic Guildgate].
Turn 3: Athar.
Athar plays [Swamp].
BigM discards [Honored Hydra].
BigM discards [Carven Caryatid].
BigM activates an ability of [Stitchwing Skaab] ( Return Stitchwing Skaab from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 4: BigM.
BigM plays [Island].
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab].
Athar exiles [Honored Hydra] with [Honored Hydra]'s ability.
BigM activates an ability of [Honored Hydra] (Embalm {3G}).
[CHAT] BigM: not a spell
[CHAT] Athar: ^^
[CHAT] Athar: ^^
Athar casts [Hero's Downfall] targeting [Honored Hydra].
Turn 4: Athar.
Athar plays [Dimir Guildgate].
Turn 5: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab].
BigM casts [Vessel of Nascency].
Turn 5: Athar.
Athar plays [Vivid Creek].
BigM casts [Catalog].
BigM draws two cards with [Catalog].
BigM discards [Wonder].
Turn 6: BigM.
BigM plays [Island].
Athar is being attacked by [Stitchwing Skaab].
Turn 6: Athar.
Athar plays [Vivid Creek].
BigM activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
BigM reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Wharf Infiltrator], [Island], [Carven Caryatid], and [Advanced Stitchwing].
BigM puts [Wharf Infiltrator] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
BigM puts [Island], [Carven Caryatid], and [Advanced Stitchwing] into their graveyard..
BigM discards [Advanced Stitchwing].
BigM discards [Revolutionary Rebuff].
BigM activates an ability of [Advanced Stitchwing] ( Return Advanced Stitchwing from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 7: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing] and [Stitchwing Skaab].
Athar casts [Azorius Charm] targeting [Advanced Stitchwing] (Put target attacking or blocking creature on top of its owner's library.).
BigM casts [Wharf Infiltrator].
Athar casts [Dissolve] targeting [Wharf Infiltrator].
Athar put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 7: Athar.
BigM discards [Revolutionary Rebuff].
BigM discards [Forest].
BigM activates an ability of [Advanced Stitchwing] ( Return Advanced Stitchwing from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 8: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing] and [Stitchwing Skaab].
Turn 8: Athar.
Athar plays [Swamp].
Athar casts [Planar Outburst].
Turn 9: BigM.
BigM casts [Advanced Stitchwing].
Athar casts [Power Sink] targeting [Advanced Stitchwing]. (X is 1).
Turn 9: Athar.
Athar plays [Island].
Athar casts [Approach of the Second Sun].
Athar puts [Approach of the Second Sun] beneath the top 6 cards of their library.
Turn 10: BigM.
Turn 10: Athar.
Athar casts [Treasure Cruise].
Athar draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
Athar plays [Vivid Creek].
BigM discards [Simic Guildgate].
BigM discards [Evolving Wilds].
BigM activates an ability of [Advanced Stitchwing] ( Return Advanced Stitchwing from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
Turn 11: BigM.
Athar is being attacked by [Advanced Stitchwing].
Athar casts [Jace's Ingenuity].
[CHAT] BigM: gg
Athar draws three cards with [Jace's Ingenuity].
Turn 11: Athar.
Athar plays [Blighted Fen].
Athar casts [Approach of the Second Sun].
Winner: Athar
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Athar: 2–1
BigM has left the game.