PennyDreadful
PDS R3 vs Giffendor
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
memlin,Gliffendor

== Game 1 (551610048) ==
PDBot has started watching.
memlin joined the game.
Gliffendor joined the game.
memlin chooses to play first.
memlin keeps this hand.
Gliffendor mulligans to 6 cards.
Gliffendor keeps this hand.
Gliffendor put a card on top of Gliffendor's library.
memlin skips their draw step.
memlin plays [Island].
Turn 1: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Crumbling Necropolis].
memlin discards [River Serpent].
memlin cycles [River Serpent].
Turn 2: memlin.
memlin plays [Arcane Sanctum].
Turn 2: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Island].
Gliffendor casts [Dreamscape Artist].
Turn 3: memlin.
memlin plays [Plains].
memlin casts [Oath of Ghouls].
Turn 3: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor plays [Island].
Gliffendor casts [Thopter Engineer].
memlin discards [River Serpent].
memlin cycles [River Serpent].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Thopter Engineer] onto the stack (When Thopter Engineer enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature tok...).
Gliffendor's [Thopter Engineer] creates a Thopter token.
memlin is being attacked by [Thopter] token and [Dreamscape Artist].
Turn 4: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [River Serpent].
[River Serpent] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin plays [Arcane Sanctum].
memlin casts [Banewhip Punisher].
memlin puts triggered ability from [Banewhip Punisher] onto the stack targeting [Thopter] token (When Banewhip Punisher enters the battlefield, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
Turn 4: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor casts [Tragic Lesson].
Gliffendor draws two cards with [Tragic Lesson].
Gliffendor discards [Kessig Malcontents].
Gliffendor plays [Cloudcrest Lake].
Turn 5: memlin.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
memlin plays [Evolving Wilds].
memlin activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card and put it onto the battlefield tapped. Then shuffle yo...).
Turn 5: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor casts [Whirler Rogue].
memlin discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
memlin cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
memlin discards [River Serpent].
memlin cycles [River Serpent].
memlin discards [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin cycles [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin discards [River Serpent].
memlin cycles [River Serpent].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Whirler Rogue] onto the stack (When Whirler Rogue enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature toke...).
Gliffendor's [Whirler Rogue] creates two Thopter tokens.
memlin is being attacked by [Thopter] token and [Thopter] token.
Turn 6: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [Glassdust Hulk].
[Glassdust Hulk] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin plays [Island].
memlin discards [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin cycles [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin casts [Corpse Connoisseur].
memlin puts triggered ability from [Corpse Connoisseur] onto the stack (When Corpse Connoisseur enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a creature card an...).
Turn 6: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor casts [Nivix Guildmage].
memlin is being attacked by [Thopter] token and [Thopter] token.
Turn 7: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [Magister of Worth].
[Magister of Worth] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin plays [Island].
memlin casts [Magister of Worth].
Gliffendor casts [Rites of Refusal] targeting [Magister of Worth].
Gliffendor discards [Kessig Malcontents].
Turn 7: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor plays [Plains].
Gliffendor casts [Kessig Malcontents].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Kessig Malcontents] onto the stack targeting memlin (When Kessig Malcontents enters the battlefield, it deals damage to target player equal to the numb...).
Gliffendor activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Corpse Connoisseur] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
memlin is being attacked by [Nivix Guildmage], [Whirler Rogue], [Thopter Engineer], and [Dreamscape Artist].
[Corpse Connoisseur] blocks [Whirler Rogue].
[Corpse Connoisseur] stops blocking.
??bug?? - [Corpse Connoisseur] has 0 targets, must have between 1 and 1 targets. Action for [Corpse Connoisseur] cannot be performed. Please report this bug and note the game state and cards involved.
[Corpse Connoisseur] blocks [Thopter Engineer].
[Banewhip Punisher] blocks [Whirler Rogue].
Turn 8: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [Magister of Worth].
[Magister of Worth] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin casts [Magister of Worth].
memlin puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...).
memlin votes for Condemnation
Gliffendor votes for Grace
Turn 8: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor casts [Whirler Rogue].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Whirler Rogue] onto the stack (When Whirler Rogue enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature toke...).
Gliffendor's [Whirler Rogue] creates two Thopter tokens.
Turn 9: memlin.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
memlin casts [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin discards [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin activates an ability of [Linessa, Zephyr Mage] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player returns a creature he or she controls to its owner's hand, then repeats this proces...).
Gliffendor returns [Whirler Rogue] to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Thopter] token to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Plains] to hand.
memlin discards [Dimir Infiltrator].
memlin transmutes [Dimir Infiltrator].
memlin reveals [Oath of Ghouls].
Turn 9: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor plays [Grand Coliseum].
Gliffendor casts [Whirler Rogue].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Whirler Rogue] onto the stack (When Whirler Rogue enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature toke...).
Gliffendor's [Whirler Rogue] creates two Thopter tokens.
Turn 10: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
[Linessa, Zephyr Mage] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin discards [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin activates an ability of [Linessa, Zephyr Mage] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player returns a creature he or she controls to its owner's hand, then repeats this proces...).
Gliffendor returns [Whirler Rogue] to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Thopter] token to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Island] to hand.
memlin discards [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin cycles [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin casts [Oath of Ghouls].
memlin casts [Oath of Ghouls].
Turn 10: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
Gliffendor plays [Island].
Gliffendor casts [Whirler Rogue].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Whirler Rogue] onto the stack (When Whirler Rogue enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature toke...).
Gliffendor's [Whirler Rogue] creates two Thopter tokens.
Gliffendor activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Thopter] token ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
memlin is being attacked by [Thopter] token.
memlin activates an ability of [Linessa, Zephyr Mage] targeting [Thopter] token. (X is 0) ( Return target creature with converted mana cost X to its owner's hand.).
memlin returns [Thopter] token to its owner's hand with [Linessa, Zephyr Mage]'s ability.
Turn 11: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [Dimir Infiltrator].
[Dimir Infiltrator] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin chooses [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
[Linessa, Zephyr Mage] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin discards [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin activates an ability of [Linessa, Zephyr Mage] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player returns a creature he or she controls to its owner's hand, then repeats this proces...).
Gliffendor returns [Whirler Rogue] to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Thopter] token to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Island] to hand.
memlin chooses [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
[Linessa, Zephyr Mage] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin discards [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin activates an ability of [Linessa, Zephyr Mage] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player returns a creature he or she controls to its owner's hand, then repeats this proces...).
Gliffendor returns [Thopter] token to hand.
Gliffendor has conceded from the game.
Winner: memlin
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (551613188) ==
PDBot has started watching.
memlin plays [Evolving Wilds].
memlin activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card and put it onto the battlefield tapped. Then shuffle yo...).
Turn 4: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Mountain].
Gliffendor casts [Dreamscape Artist].
memlin discards [River Serpent].
memlin cycles [River Serpent].
memlin discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
memlin cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
Turn 4: memlin.
memlin plays [Swamp].
memlin casts [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin discards [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin activates an ability of [Linessa, Zephyr Mage] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player returns a creature he or she controls to its owner's hand, then repeats this proces...).
Gliffendor returns [Dreamscape Artist] to hand.
Gliffendor returns [Mountain] to hand.
Turn 5: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Mountain].
Gliffendor discards [Kessig Malcontents].
Gliffendor discards [Dreamscape Artist].
Gliffendor casts [Cathartic Reunion].
Gliffendor draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion].
Turn 5: memlin.
memlin discards [Glassdust Hulk].
memlin cycles [Glassdust Hulk].
Gliffendor is being attacked by [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin discards [River Serpent].
memlin cycles [River Serpent].
memlin casts [Thran Foundry].
memlin plays [Evolving Wilds].
memlin activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card and put it onto the battlefield tapped. Then shuffle yo...).
Turn 6: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Grand Coliseum].
Turn 6: memlin.
memlin plays [Island].
Gliffendor casts [Lightning Strike] targeting [Linessa, Zephyr Mage].
memlin casts [Thran Foundry].
Gliffendor casts [Rites of Refusal] targeting [Thran Foundry].
Gliffendor discards [Grand Coliseum].
Gliffendor discards [Ancient Amphitheater].
Gliffendor discards [Whirler Rogue].
Turn 7: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Cloudcrest Lake].
Turn 7: memlin.
memlin casts [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
[CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Oriss, Samite Guardian[sU] has a Disadvantageous bug.  Using [Oriss, Samite Guardian]'s Grandeur ability during controller's precombat main phase will not allow controller to attack that turn.
Turn 8: Gliffendor.
memlin discards [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
memlin activates an ability of [Oriss, Samite Guardian] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player can't cast spells this turn, and creatures that player controls can't attack this t...).
Gliffendor plays [Ancient Amphitheater].
Turn 8: memlin.
memlin casts [Memoricide] targeting Gliffendor.
memlin names Angel of Glory's Rise for [Memoricide].
bakert99 has started watching.
Gliffendor is being attacked by [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
Turn 9: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Island].
bakert99 has stopped watching.
Turn 9: memlin.
Gliffendor is being attacked by [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
memlin casts [Magister of Worth].
memlin puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...).
memlin votes for Grace
Gliffendor votes for Condemnation
GotThisForSOI has started watching.
Turn 10: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor plays [Mountain].
Gliffendor casts [Thopter Engineer].
Gliffendor puts triggered ability from [Thopter Engineer] onto the stack (When Thopter Engineer enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature tok...).
Gliffendor's [Thopter Engineer] creates a Thopter token.
Turn 10: memlin.
Gliffendor is being attacked by [Magister of Worth].
Turn 11: Gliffendor.
Gliffendor casts [Dreamscape Artist].
Turn 11: memlin.
memlin casts [Oath of Ghouls].
memlin casts [Oath of Ghouls].
Gliffendor is being attacked by [Magister of Worth].
Turn 12: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
[CHAT] GotThisForSOI: !record
[CHAT] PDBot: [sD]Record:  memlin 1-0 Gliffendor
Gliffendor casts [Ironwright's Cleansing] targeting [Oath of Ghouls].
Gliffendor discards [Cathartic Reunion].
Gliffendor activates an ability of [Dreamscape Artist] ( Search your library for up to two basic land cards and put them onto the battlefield. Then shuffl...).
Turn 12: memlin.
memlin puts triggered ability from [Oath of Ghouls] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses target player whose graveyard has fe...).
memlin targets Gliffendor for Triggered ability from Oath of Ghouls.
memlin chooses [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
[Oriss, Samite Guardian] is returned to memlin's hand from the graveyard.
memlin plays [Arcane Sanctum].
Gliffendor is being attacked by [Magister of Worth].
[Thopter] token blocks [Magister of Worth].
memlin casts [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
Turn 13: Gliffendor.
No legal targets to choose for [Oath of Ghouls]'s triggered ability.
memlin discards [Oriss, Samite Guardian].
memlin activates an ability of [Oriss, Samite Guardian] targeting Gliffendor ( Target player can't cast spells this turn, and creatures that player controls can't attack this t...).
[CHAT] Gliffendor: gg, nice lock, my deck still needs a lot of tuning
Gliffendor has conceded from the game.
Winner: memlin
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: memlin: 2–0
memlin has left the game.